Paranormal Series Part 2: The Kirkbride – A Symbol Of Timeless Terror And Tragedy

More than 120 years ago, the Fergus Falls State Hospital loomed over its titular city as a symbol of governmental care for a group of people society preferred didn’t exist. Today, the complex symbolizes what is becoming all-too-common across the country: an outdated structure of languishing usefulness and mysterious existence.

What’s left behind is now a hollow shell of crumbling plaster, overgrown brush, and dismantled rooms. But it’s far from empty. In fact, some say it’s haunted.

The paranormal organization that investigated the Forum basement also spent time at the Fergus Falls State Hospital three years ago. They investigated the facility on two different occasions, recording several EVP sessions. Some of the recordings produced sounds—knocking and whistling. But some produced voices. Saying “hi.” Answering the investigators question about whether people were with them that night with a “Yes, they are.”

And most creepily… raspy pleas of “Get me out of here.”

Scared yet? But they’re just voices… right?

Voices are the only thing left for the Kirkbride. Voices from the past, yearning to be heard. Voices of the present, fighting to save the building from imminent destruction. Voices from the future, hoping to invigorate a building currently rendered useless.

Goosebumps and Gloom

The creepiest thing about the Kirkbride is not the prospect of spirits or paranormal activity; that’s to be expected for an institution where heinous acts were carried out in the name of medicine. Psychiatric care has evolved incredibly in the last century, but not without costly human carnage.

What’s creepy is how well the complex has held up in the battle against time.

IMG_0948The Fergus Falls building is the most complete of all remaining Kirkbride buildings—the only thing gone is the portico on the face of the iconic administration building. Of the 16 Kirkbride buildings in the country, six have been partially or completely demolished.

Will the Fergus Falls Kirkbride be next? Or, will it be a success story like the Traverse City State Hospital in Michigan that has been transformed into one of the largest historic preservation and adaptive reuse redevelopments?

While touring the Kirkbride in Fergus Falls, it’s nearly impossible not to feel sad. That gloom—it’s called kenopsia—overtakes you as you survey the eerie, forlorn atmosphere of an abandoned place no longer bustling with people.

The tour guide acknowledges that bad things happened within its walls, but good things happened, too. The sweet old lady and her elderly husband who snake you through the hallways and stairwells recite fact after astonishing fact—most sugarcoated into a benign retelling of a building that has outlived its usefulness. They’ve been giving tours of the infamous building for 11 years, educating people from 43 states and 10 countries about the institution; they play their parts to perfection.

So do the buildings. From the overrun, imposing Tudor-style nurses dormitory to the detention and contagious disease buildings dotting the perimeter of the property, the Kirkbride brims with possibility… and sorrow for the sad decline the building has seen in the past 50 years.IMG_4762

Crumbling walls shed plaster tears. Gaping holes in the most opulent rooms indicate where worthy remnants have long-since been torn from the walls to fetch a few dollars at auction.

It’s a cursory look at the nearly 900,000-square-foot facility… but it’s enough.

To truly understand the mystique surrounding the Fergus Falls State Hospital, you have to know why it was built in the first place and how truly terrifying its downfall has been.

Settle in. This is a complicated history about a complex building at a dynamic time in history.

Lock Up The Lunatics

After the Civil War, state hospitals were used as “holding pens for societal dregs and outcasts where little rehabilitation took place…inebriates (drunkards and addicts), imbeciles (mentally deficient), and mentally ill patients were all housed together,” according to The State Welcomes You: Minnesota’s Third State Hospital, Fergus Falls.*

Operating room 1900
Operating room in state hospital on display in lobby.

In the late 1880s, Minnesota’s two state hospitals in St. Peter and Rochester burgeoned with mentally ill patients. The overcrowding caused disgraceful conditions—lack of space and plumbing, poor ventilation and drainage, neglected and mistreated patients, filthy livestock that roamed freely about the grounds. And in 1880 the situation turned dangerous when a fire destroyed a wing at the Rochester State Hospital, killing 24 patients.

A third facility was crucial. But where would it go? The hospitals in St. Peter and Rochester adequately served the southern and eastern portions of the state, so a northern location was sought. Fergus Falls contended with Alexandria, Brainerd, Sauk Center, Little Falls, Lake Park and Detroit Lakes.

Thanks to some “intense politicking”, Fergus Falls secured the hospital in 1887, and the legislature purchased land for $24,280. Architect Warren Dunnell designed the complex based on the plan Dr. Thomas Kirkbride had created. Kirkbride pioneered a new standard for mental health treatment based on the tenets of the moral treatment.

IMG_4704Kirkbride promoted a design principle for American asylums that promoted cheerfulness, natural light, open spaces, and abundant fresh air. The Fergus Falls State Hospital was designed according to his linear plan and included a farm for patients to engage in manual labor as therapy.

Even today, in its desolate condition, you can appreciate its expansive views and ample space. Enclosed outdoor porches provided fresh air, and the facility’s open-door policy meant patients could explore the campus freely.

From Peaceful to Panicked

Constructing the state hospital took 12 years, but the first patients were admitted as soon as the west ward was completed in 1890. Those first patients were admitted for “epilepsy, intemperance, injury to head, disappointment in love and overwork.”*

The open-door policy may seem strange for a facility housing mentally unstable individuals; however, the moral treatment plan focused on handling patients like people (rather than prisoners) and called for a regimen of hot milk and rest. The hospital’s first superintendent, Dr. Alonzo Williamson, asserted that those two “forces” were responsible for the fact that physical restraints were not needed.

A Fergus Falls Weekly reporter visited the hospital and wrote that he was greeted by a patient who exclaimed, “The state welcomes you, sir.” The writer compared the state hospital to a summer resort. However, as the facility filled with more unruly patients, that initial peace became a distant memory.

straight jacket
Unruly patients wore straight jackets like these*

So distant that special rules had to be imposed after unfortunate incidents began occurring, such as a hydrotherapy session that went horribly awry. A patient was burned so severely that she died five days later. In another case, a patient scrubbing the floor became unruly and accidentally killed another patient with the cleaning tool.*

Experimenting With People’s Lives

Terms used for mentally ill people in the 1920s included “feebleminded” and “moron,” according to American Pyschosis: How the Federal Government Destroyed the Mental Illness Treatment System.** It was the peak of the eugenics craze; male “morons” were thought to end us as criminals while female morons, tended toward prostitution, making state hospitals a critical component of community safety.

Crowded men's ward
Day rooms were used for patient overflow*

By the 1930s, the Fergus Falls State Hospital found itself vastly overcrowded and woefully underfunded. Patient numbers peaked in March 1937 with 2,078 individuals confined within the hospital walls, despite the facility’s 1,890 patient capacity. Day rooms and hallways were filled with patient beds.

In the east ward of the complex, those day rooms now stand empty, largely unchanged from over a century ago. Fraying white curtains still hang from the ceilings, wafting eerily in the still air.

The state hospital suffered more after World War II ended; personnel and funding became even more scarce, yet unstable patients continued to stream through the doors.

IMG_0930Dr. William Patterson, the hospital’s third (and most long-standing) superintendent, did what he could to attract and retain workers. He added amenities like a beauty shop, diner, coffee shop, greenhouse, and auto repair shop. His wife Marguerite started an internal newspaper called The Weekly Pulse to update employees and patients on hospital news and activities.

Amenities weren’t the only thing changing at the state hospital. Treatment continued to evolve, including things like psychotherapy, electroconvulsive therapy, and tranquilizing drugs. The lobotomy also emerged as a form of therapy, despite controversy.

The lobotomy had been pioneered in Portugal and was brought to the United States in 1936 by Doctors  Walter Freeman, a neurologist, and James Watts, a neurosurgeon.** By 1941, Freeman and Watts had performed lobotomies on almost 100 mentally ill patients and were claiming good results for many of them, especially those with symptoms of agitated depression and obsessive-compulsive symptoms.**

That same year, those two men performed the catastrophic lobotomy on Rosemary Kennedy that would eventually have repercussions for the entire federal mental health care system.

Hundreds of miles away in Fergus Falls, lobotomies were performed on mentally ill patients at the state hospital. One such procedure was accidentally witnessed by a Fergus Falls High School vocational class visiting the facility.*

medical kit
Dr. William Patterson’s medical kit*

Imagine being a high school student listening to presentation after presentation by stuffy medical personnel. You’re in a patient room expecting another explanation of hospital policies and procedures. Suddenly, the doctor picks up a drill and bores holes into a patient’s skull; he then sticks a wire-like tube through the holes and turns it, severing the frontal brain lobe. That’s a lobotomy.

Slicing up a person’s brain became less necessary with the introduction of anti-psychotic drugs, sparking a revolution in how mentally ill patients were treated.

One of the great ironies of American psychiatric history is that during 1955, at the same time that the Joint Commission on Mental Illness and Health was being charged with finding a solution to the mental illness crisis, a totally unexpected solution was appearing. The solution was chlorpromazine, sold in the U.S. under the trade name Thorazine. It had been discovered in France in 1952 and reported to dramatically reduce the delusions, hallucinations, and manic symptoms of many patients with severe psychiatric disorders.**

Deinstitutionalizing the Institutions

IMG_4994
April 27, 1958 Forum article

By the 1950s, large facilities housing mentally ill patients were no longer en vogue, thanks to information from the aforementioned Joint Commission on Mental Illness and Health. The findings signaled the beginning of the slow, tragic decline of the Fergus Falls State Hospital.

The commission’s report, “largely ideological” and “sufficiently ambiguous to allow various interest groups to read what they wished into it,” declared in 1961 that state mental hospitals were “bankrupt beyond remedy”.** Community mental health centers (one for every 100,000 people) were recommended, and the president of the American Psychiatric Association recommended that state mental hospitals should all be “liquidated as rapidly as can be done in an orderly and progressive fashion.”

October 31, 2015, marks the 52nd anniversary of President John F. Kennedy signing the landmark Community Mental Health Act. The legislation called for mental health centers across America that would allow individuals to be treated while working and living at home, instead of being neglected or possibly abused in state institutions. Without ever mentioning his sister, Kennedy hoped to eliminate other instances of family members being torn from their families and hidden in facilities miles away. Less than a month later, Kennedy was dead.

Fergus Falls tried to keep pace…unsuccessfully.

IMG_5003
This September 1958 Forum article describes then-Minnesota Gov. Luther Youngdahl reacting to conditions in state hospitals.

In 1971, the state hospital became Minnesota’s first regional center (officially changing its name to the Fergus Falls Regional Treatment Center in 1985). In 1973, the direct care staff was reduced, sparking outrage among the center’s advocates. In a Forum article, Bill Johnson said the reduction had turned the center into “at best only a custodial program” and “at worse…a warehouse of dehumanized humanity whose dignity and worth is being assaulted daily on all sides.”

Protests fell on deaf ears. Stories continued to emerge in local newspapers about escaped patients and their subsequent crimes, budget deficits, and program cuts. Staff numbers wore thin. Patients were transferred elsewhere. Entire sections of the massive Fergus Falls facility went completely unused. Across the country, state psychiatric hospitals beds were being eliminated—a total of 432,633 were cut from 1955 to 1981. And where did those mentally ill patients go? Right into the community where they were supposed to receive care…but didn’t.

American Psychosis author Torrey writes:

The patients being discharged to live in the community by this stage were the sickest and most difficult to manage. They were the patients who were most in need of well-organized community mental health services…The primary concern of most state mental health agencies was to continue emptying their hospitals as quickly as possible, thereby shifting the cost to the federal government and saving state funds. Where the patients went was of lesser concern.

During the centennial celebration of the Fergus Falls facility, CEO Elaine Timmer remained upbeat. “We’re real proud of the fact that we have been able to provide 100 years of continuous service and look forward to providing 100 more. We are on the verge of significant change in the organization,” Timmer said in a July 15, 1990, Forum article. Timmer eventually left the organization in 1995 to join its overseeing entity, the Minnesota Department of Human Services.

The End Is Near…?

IMG_0886By the early 2000s, patient numbers dwindled to just more than 100 individuals being treated for “mental illness, chemical dependency, and detoxification.” In 2005, the center closed and two years later the state sold the land to the city of Fergus Falls. It took another two years for the entire structure to be completely vacated.

Now what?

Referred to as “The Kirkbride,” the facility still rises above the skyline of Fergus Falls… for now. As a national historic place, the building seems to have escaped the prospect of demolition.

Except that it hasn’t. The city argues that the building is simply too big and too costly to redevelop. In 2004, the Preservation Alliance of Minnesota listed the Fergus Falls Regional Treatment Center as one of the most endangered buildings in the state.

The Friends of the Kirkbride organization is working tirelessly to save the center; the situation was looking up when, in 2013, the city hired a developer, but those hopes evaporated this summer when the city cut ties with the company.

Back to Square One

Friends of the Kirkbride host tours of the building free of charge, hoping to inspire others to join the fundraising cause that will enable continued use. Tours are full for 2015, but you can schedule one for 2016… if the complex isn’t torn down by then.

IMG_0909That’s the biggest worry for advocates. They are doing everything they can to demonstrate the building’s usefulness. Imagine Fergus Falls is a joint effort of the Springboard for the Arts, the Fergus Falls Economic Improvement Commission, the Otter Tail County Historical Society, and PlaceBase Productions. Imagine Fergus Falls aims to foster community interaction about historic preservation through innovative arts programming and community storytelling.

Nancy Cook toured the center in October to learn more about its history. She was one of the artists in residents brought in through Imagine Fergus Falls and Springboard to host a creative writing project focusing on the Kirkbride. She held workshops on Saturdays for local writers and will help produce an anthology of the work inspired by the building.

Other efforts that are keeping the Kirkbride front and center include a recent presentation of “Walking the Tightrope,” a play based on the journal of an actual Fergus Falls State Hospital patient named Victor M. Victor. On Friday, you can watch “Geist,” a movie filmed at the Kirkbride; the film is being shown at Legacy Hall at the Fergus Falls M | State campus.

In its heyday, the Fergus Falls State Hospital was a beacon of modern medicine, a cathedral of care for the discarded masses of society who had nowhere else to go. Today, it’s a terrifying and mysterious relic of the past with an uncertain future… and time may be running out.

Epilogue

American Psychosis was not written about the Fergus Falls State Hospital…directly (interestingly enough, the cover photo was taken within its men’s ward). But the book so elegantly explains how the very effort meant to revitalize the mental health treatment system actually enabled its downfall.

(The new mental health and retardation) program (meant to honor Rosemary Kennedy) involved closing state psychiatric hospitals, shifting outpatient care to federally funded community mental health centers, and preventing mental illnesses. As implemented, the new federal program effectively lobotomized both the existing and the emerging state mental health programs. The federal program has been a disaster, and the current chaotic, dysfunctional mental health system is, in one sense, Rosemary’s baby.

State mental hospitals had been a mainstay of public psychiatric care in the country for more than a century. Reversing that policy involved shifting patients who’d been hospitalized for years, possibly decades. Federal programs were meant to replace the care in a more sophisticated, mature style, but the implementation and execution was clumsy, to say the least. The resulting disaster continues to plague the mental health industry today. American Psychosis author Torrey asserts that:

For the majority of people with serious mental illnesses, the situation is little better today than it was in 1947, when Frank Wright, in Out of Sight, Out of Mind, noted: Throughout history the problem of the mentally ill has been dodged. We have continually avoided mental patients – we have segregated them, ostracized them, turned our backs on them, tried to forget them. We have allowed intolerable conditions to exist for the mentally ill through our ignorance and indifference. We can no longer afford to disregard their needs, to turn a deaf ear to their call for help. We must come face to face with the facts.

*Information found in The State Welcomes You: Minnesota’s Third State Hospital Fergus Falls published by the Otter Tail County Historical Society.

**Information from American Psychosis: How the Federal Government Destroyed the Mental Illness Treatment System by E. Fuller Torrey.

Featured Image courtesy Friends of the Kirkbride Facebook page; taken by Steve Janssen.

Part 1: A Spirited Forum Basement
Part 3: The Haunted Memories of a Gruesome Pig Farm Murder
Part 4: A Midnight Trip to the Graveyard

 

 

11 Responses

  1. Barbara Carlson

    My mom got pregnant at the age of 16 (1951) so her parents sent her to some place in Fergus Falls. Would this have been the place that housed wayward girls. Her baby was taken from her and adopted out.

    1. Danielle Teigen

      Hi Barbara – The research I used did not indicate anything about wayward girls being served at the state hospital, but that’s not to say the facility didn’t take them in from time to time. Thank you for reading!

      Danielle

  2. Valerie

    Throughout history, all mental institutions evolved in their treatment of patients, just as regular medicine did. I know there were horrors in the early years of psychiatry , but all the years I was employed at RTC, I have fond memories of residents and staff. Most employees were dedicated and loving and I remember happy experiences.
    As for the paranormal, I use to work nights on the units (3 NE) and I use to see images and noises that were often undetectable. i know those walls hold secrets and voices!

    1. Danielle Teigen

      Thank you for your comment, Valerie. I appreciate you pointing out that you enjoyed your time at the treatment center. That seems to be the case with many former employees. Thanks for reading!

      Danielle

  3. Grace

    Dear Danielle Teigen,

    This article made me sick to my stomach. I had to stop reading it because it’s very disrespectful to those that spend all their time/energy trying to preserve this building for future generations to enjoy.

    1. Danielle Teigen

      I’m sorry you feel that way, Grace. The article was not written to disrespect anyone but rather to retell the building’s history while also describing the current efforts to repurpose it. Because you stopped reading, you may have missed the two sections of the article that talk about how the Friends of the Kirkbride are working tirelessly to save the building as well as the Imagine Fergus Falls effort bringing awareness and arts to the facility.

      Danielle

  4. shelly

    Maybe there would b more support if it was easier to tour. Last time I checked tours were only done on Fridays from 11-2. Most people work during that time. How about an evening tour or a weekend ?

    1. Danielle Teigen

      You have a good point, Shelly. You are correct about the tours, but that could also be necessary considering that the tour guides are all volunteers. Perhaps you want to reach out to the Friends of the Kirkbride to start a discussion on tour availability. You can reach them through http://www.friendsofthekirkbride.com.

      Danielle

  5. BeckyC

    I remember my neighbors Son was sent there, he was down Syndrome, he would get to come “home” for a visit week or two. I remember going there once with them to pick him up. Greg was NOTHING to be feared or afraid of at all ever. Eventually he got to be placed in a group home for Adults with Developmental Challenges. I later went there in 2001, when they had it a an alcohol treatment facility, all I can remember is when walking thru those halls to get to a meeting room, I could literally feel the presence of others, and the smell I could smell, but those with me could not smell it. I got goose bumps and chills.
    Your writing and history of the Kirkland is excellent, and very detailed historically. I many ways I do hope that that building can be restructured into some thing very positive for the community and the state, but I seriously feel it does need to spiritually cleansed, and those “spirits” that do remain there, should be heard, addressed and above all helped to cross over to where they wish to go. There are many in that field that are able to do and help with that, and I do not mean specifically with in the “church institutions”. Once the spiritual blessing/cleansing is done and followed up on, then I believe that everything positive will be able to move forward in a good way.

    1. Danielle Teigen

      Thanks for the comment, Becky. I agree with you that a spiritual cleansing could be great for the facility, and I also hope a developer soon sees the beauty of the Kirkbride and redevelops it for use for generations to come.

      Danielle

Leave a Reply